Home » FfL Articles » Food & Nutrition » Real Food » The Dirty Truth About Grocery Store Nut Butter (Spoiler Alert)

The Dirty Truth About Grocery Store Nut Butter (Spoiler Alert)

When it comes to nut butter, it's important to be aware that many big companies use misleading language to make consumers believe that their product is genuine. Unfortunately, most of the jars you find in supermarkets are filled with anywhere from 4 to over 14 heavily processed ingredients. In this spoiler alert, we'll uncover the dirty truth about which grocery store nut butters are the real deal and which ones are subpar spreads.

What’s one food in your kitchen that you can’t live without? For me (Kalie), it’s nut butter. It tastes delicious, and in my opinion, the way it sticks to the roof of your mouth before it melts is absolutely wonderful. It started out as an innocent craving that turned into a full blown LOVE AFFAIR. I went from enjoying peanut butter on occasion to eating almond butter on the reg.

Our family loves it on Apple Slices with Nibs, Rice Cakes with Bananas, Berry Stuffed French Toast and, my personal favorite, Dreamy Apple Cinnamon Toast. The list goes on and on!

Which nut butters should you avoid and which should you welcome into your home?

I love looking at labels (I know, I’m an odd bird), and peanut butter is one of the world’s most popular spreads, so I wanted to spend some time at the store checking out the big name nut butters that fill our market shelves.

What I discovered was this... nut butters fall into ONE of TWO categories

  • Highly processed junk food
  • Minimally processed and good for you, in moderation of course

Because minimally processed nut butter is PACKED with protein, low in carbs and HIGH in healthy fats, we (here at FULLforLife) consider it a good addition to your diet (again in moderation), as long as it’s the real deal.

Since many of you and your families love nut butter as much as our family does, I wanted to share my findings when it comes to creamy or crunchy nut-buttery goodness!

What should you steer clear of when it comes to nut butters

A common theme I found was that A LOT of the big name companies (the ones that you and your kids would typically gravitate to) use sneaky words to trick us (the consumer) into thinking that their product is actually nut butter.

Most of the jars I picked up contained anywhere from 4 to over 14 unnecessary ingredients. Some said Natural but contained ingredients that were ANYTHING but natural. One jar said it was made with honey, but it was the last ingredient listed (yes, after sugar). Others didn’t even say exactly what they were, which led me to wonder, are they a nut butter, a spread… or something else?

The most frustrating thing was, all of these brands had big pictures of nuts to lead you to believe they were the real deal.

Here’s a Look at Some of Those Deceiving Labels…

Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread

  • This spread (meaning it’s made with less than 90% peanuts) contains sugar and palm oil as main ingredients… no thank you!

Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread with HONEY

  • Don’t let the label deceive you. Sugar is the main sweetener used, not honey. Honey is listed as the last ingredient, meaning it’s used the least.

Jiff Reduced Fat Creamy Peanut Butter Spread

  • This nut butter spread is one of the most highly processed of the bunch. It’s made with only 60% nuts and contains 16 ingredients, many of which I can barely pronounce:
    • Peanuts, Corn Syrup Solids, Sugar, Pea Protein, Contains 2% Or Less Of: Salt, Fully Hydrogenated Vegetable Oils (Rapeseed And Soybean), Mono And Diglycerides, Molasses, Magnesium Oxide, Niacinamide, Ferric Orthophosphate, Zinc Oxide, Copper Sulfate, Folic Acid, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride.

One of the "good ones"...

Adam's Peanut Butter

  • One ingredient… the nut itself.

Another AWESOME and inexpensive option

Grind Your Own

  • One ingredient… the nut itself.
  • Grinders can be found at some grocery stores, whole food stores and co-ops.
  • You can grind your own nut butter at home with a food processor or high-speed blender.

So in a nutshell (no pun intended), here's what to steer clear of when it comes to nut butter

  • Avoid nut butter spreads. It should say “nut butter” NOT “nut butter spread.” Spreads consist of less than 90% nuts and who knows what else?!
  • Avoid nut butters with added sweeteners such as sugar, corn syrup or molasses.
  • Avoid nut butters with added oils such as hydrogenated vegetable oils.
  • Basically, avoid anything other than nut butters made with just the nut.

What you want in a nut butter

  • The nut, or a combination of nuts, ground up into nutty goodness, that’s it! …and maybe a limited amount of salt.

Our go-to brand

Take Action

  • Take inventory of your pantry and eliminate nut butter spreads or nut butters with added oils or sugars.
  • Replace them with 100% natural nut butter containing only the nut and limited salt.
  • If you haven’t tried any nut butters other than peanut butter, consider purchasing a nut butter blend or one made with cashews, almonds, sunflower seeds, pecans or walnuts.

Let's enjoy nut-buttery goodness that's made with REAL ingredients — together!

Cheers to a healthy lifestyle and living FULLforLife!
xo, Pam & Kalie

Treat Yourself to a Weekly Wellness Boost!

Unlock VIP access to self-care secrets, delightful surprises, and a dash of healthy food inspiration. Join us now and let the pampering begin!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Take the next step & get started with a real-food lifestyle today!

With a few simple swaps, you can go from lethargic to energized and on your A-game.

The proven strategies in the Healthy Eating Made Simple Course will allow you to stock your kitchen with healthy food that fits your lifestyle needs.

Get Started Now!

You May Also Enjoy

Leave a Comment


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi beautiFULL, We’re Pam and Kalie

If you want your family to live a healthier life, you’ve come to the right place! Our simple wellness practices have been handed down for three generations and are the secret weapon to staying healthy and sane.

Learn More




Real Food Crash Course

Learn how to cut out processed food in a realistic and manageable way.

Free Guide Food – Real Food Crash Course

"*" indicates required fields