Home » Food » Healthy Staples » Toppings and Condiments

Toppings and Condiments

Real-food or really unhealthy?

Store-bought toppings and condiments tend to get a bad rap for obvious reasons—many are filled with rancid and hydrogenated oils and fats, loads of sugar, synthetic preservatives, flavor enhancers and artificial dyes. On the flip side, store-bought versions really come in handy when you’re too busy to make homemade versions.

In today’s roundup, we’re going to dive into the topic of Toppings and Condiments and talk about how to find real-food versions in the grocery store. We’ll also share some simple, healthy swaps you can make in place of unhealthy, high-fat or sugary items.

How to shop for real-food toppings and condiments

If you frequent the FULLforLife website or our social media channels, you’ve probably heard us say more than once that when purchasing something in a box, bottle, package or can, reading the ingredients list is the only way to make an informed choice about your purchase. Why? Because it’s the only way to know what’s actually used to make that food (and whether it’s truly food or a nutrient-less substance).

A few pointers

For starters, check out the ingredients label and choose toppings and condiments with a short list of ingredients that you’re familiar with (aim for less than seven).

Next, look at the ingredients listed. If you wouldn’t find an ingredient listed on the label in your pantry or fridge (like natural flavoring or artificial coloring) then it’s probably a good idea to ditch it and move on to another brand.

Additionally, think about whether or not you could make the item at home without an ingredient listed (like oil or sugar). This is one reason why learning to cook is important. When you know how to make certain foods, you know that many of the extra fillers (like hydrogenated oils and high fructose corn syrup) are not necessary. If you don’t know your way around the kitchen, no need to stress, we have all the articles and resources you need to learn.

Lastly, be aware of the fat, sugar and salt content. Because people tend to use more than an average 1 tablespoon per serving, make sure they don’t contain more than 3-5 grams of sugar per serving, that the sodium is kept to a minimum, and that the fats used are quality fats, such as avocado oil, extra virgin olive oil, flaxseed oil, sesame seed oil or walnut oil.

Avoid items made with these ingredients

It’s important to know how to weed through the ultra-processed “food” and find real-food options. Along with ingredients that are clearly unrecognizable, here are some ingredients to avoid, or at least minimize, when shopping for toppings and condiments. You’ll find that many of these ingredients are standard in ultra-processed “food.

  • Artificial sweeteners and refined sugars like high fructose corn syrup (HFCS)
  • Vegetable oils: palm, soy, corn, safflower, canola or cottonseed
  • Hydrogenated oils or trans fats
  • Artificial ingredients, coloring and dyes
  • Unfamiliar ingredients
  • Moderate to high amounts of sugar

Focus on swapping out one item at a time

Making the switch to a real-food lifestyle can feel overwhelming. Remember that a lifestyle is created by taking one small step at a time, not transitioning your entire kitchen at once. When you notice something is getting low, make a note on your grocery list and restock it with an FfL-friendly, real-food version. That way you can build your real-food kitchen, one ingredient at a time, without stress or shock to your budget and taste buds.

A few brands we love and enjoy

Today we have to balance eating real food and living in the modern world. Thankfully, more companies are stepping up to meet the demand for real-food convenience. Below are a few of our favorites:

Primal Kitchen

Hands down our absolute favorite and go-to for condiments, sauces and dressings

Noble Made

Sir Kensington

Some delicious real-food swaps

Be aware! You can drastically increase your fat, sugar and calorie intake if you don’t choose toppings and condiments wisely and watch your portions. A few simple swaps you’ll find whenever hanging out in our kitchen are:

  • Plain Greek yogurt rather than mayonnaise or sour cream
  • Across the board, we substitute Greek yogurt in any recipe that calls for mayo or sour cream. We use a 1:1 ratio when substituting.
  • Consider salsa, hot sauce, avocados or veggies to top a baked potato rather than using cheese, sour cream or butter.
  • Consider topping your salads and sandwiches with items like avocado, tapenade, hummus and roasted red peppers for a boost in flavor rather than using heavy dressings or mayonnaise.
  • Rather than using a sugary dressing, we almost always add a small amount of fruit to our side salads (diced apples or berries are our favorite). Extra virgin olive oil and pure balsamic vinegar pair wonderfully with fruit as a dressing.
  • Boiled down berries, such as our Blueberry Compote recipe, can be made with little-to-no effort and is a great substitute for sugary jellies and jams.

Deliciously Simple Real-food Condiments, Toppings and Dip Recipes

We believe a good condiment can turn any meal from boring to delicious, but recommend that you’re choosy when it comes to selecting ones that are best for your health. If you can’t find real-food versions at the store, try making your own. If they’re freezer-friendly, make a double batch to freeze and enjoy later.


Savory Toppings and Dips

Sweet Toppings and Dips

Take action today

  1. Check all the condiments in your kitchen and eliminate any condiments with “no-no” ingredients. Replace them with acceptable items.
  2. Try making your own condiment, topping or dip.

To learn more about real-food basics, check out the rest of our Healthy Staples!

Cheers to a healthy lifestyle and living FULLforLife!
xo, Pam & Kalie

Hi beautiFULL, We’re Pam and Kalie

If you want your family to live a healthier life, you’ve come to the right place! Our simple wellness practices have been handed down for three generations and are the secret weapon to staying healthy and sane.

Learn More

Food Articles


Eating Healthy Today

1. Easy To Get Started

This is where your journey begins! With an abundance of resources at your fingertips, choose the path that speaks to your area of concern.

2. Utilize Proven Strategies

Our stellar toolbox is complete with videos, guides and an array of whole food recipes, printable checklists and cheat sheets... all designed to help you easily cut out highly processed foods and fill your kitchen with food you and your whole family will not only love but thrive from!

3. Stay Connected with a Supportive Community

You’ll never be alone on your journey to healthy eating! If you’re looking for connection, you can join other women, along with the two of us (Pam and Kalie), in our private Facebook group where you’ll make friends, share ideas and receive encouragement anytime you need it.


Helped Other Readers Just Like You

Years Professional Experience

Lives Transformed

Hours Teaching & Coaching

Lectures, Workshops & Events


Amazing Results


Real Food Crash Course

Learn how to cut out processed food in a realistic and manageable way.

Free Guide Food – Real Food Crash Course

"*" indicates required fields